How to Start a Nonprofit Podcast: A Step-by-Step Guide

How to Start a Nonprofit Podcast: A Step-by-Step Guide

Podcasts have become a powerful medium for mission-driven organizations. They offer something other content formats can't: extended time with your audience, deep exploration of topics that matter, and the intimacy of voice-to-ear connection.

But starting a podcast is easier to romanticize than to execute. For every successful nonprofit podcast, there are dozens that launched enthusiastically and faded after a few episodes.

This guide walks through what it actually takes to start a nonprofit podcast that serves your mission—and realistic considerations for whether it's right for your organization.

Is a Podcast Right for Your Organization?

Before diving into how, consider whether:

Podcasting Makes Sense If:

You have ongoing stories to tell. Podcasts require consistent content. Organizations with regular programmatic activity, expert perspectives, or community stories have natural material.

Your audience consumes audio. Consider whether your supporters actually listen to podcasts. Younger donors and professional audiences often do. Some demographics don't engage with the format.

You can commit to consistency. A podcast that publishes sporadically loses audience trust. You need capacity to produce episodes regularly (biweekly or monthly at minimum) for at least a year.

You have a distinct voice or perspective. What makes your podcast worth listening to over the thousands of others? Mission alignment alone isn't enough—you need a compelling angle.

Podcasting May Not Make Sense If:

You're stretched too thin already. Podcasting requires ongoing time investment. If your team can barely handle current communications, adding a podcast will likely underperform.

Your audience doesn't consume podcasts. Some demographics simply don't engage with the format. Know your audience before investing.

You don't have a long-term commitment. A podcast that runs for six episodes and stops can damage your credibility more than help. Better to start with a limited series if you're uncertain.

Video would serve better. Sometimes organizations want a podcast when they really need testimonial videos or other content. Be honest about what problem you're solving.

Step 1: Define Your Podcast Concept

Before equipment or recording, get clear on what makes your podcast worth listening to.

Identify Your Unique Angle

What perspective can your organization offer that others can't?

Possible angles:

• Inside access to your mission and the people you serve

• Expert commentary on issues in your sector

• Voices typically unheard in mainstream media

• Deep dives into topics your audience cares about

• Community conversations with stakeholders and partners

The best nonprofit podcasts don't just talk about their work—they provide genuine value to listeners whether or not they ever donate.

Define Your Audience

Who specifically is this podcast for?

• Current supporters who want deeper connection?

• Potential donors you're cultivating?

• Peers in your sector?

• People passionate about your cause who don't know you yet?

Different audiences require different approaches. Clarity here shapes everything else.

Choose Your Format

Common podcast formats that work for nonprofits:

Interview format: Host conversations with experts, beneficiaries, partners, or leaders. Requires strong interview skills and ongoing guest pipeline.

Narrative storytelling: Produced stories about your mission and impact. Higher production requirements but potentially more compelling.

Panel discussions: Multiple voices discussing topics. Requires good facilitation and clear structure.

Solo commentary: A leader sharing insights and perspectives. Requires strong on-mic presence and consistent ideas.

Hybrid: Mixing formats across episodes. Offers variety but requires more planning.

Set Realistic Goals

What does success look like?

• Downloads per episode?

• Donor engagement or cultivation?

• Awareness and reach?

• Thought leadership positioning?

• Community building?

Set specific, measurable goals you'll evaluate against after your first season.

Step 2: Plan Your Production

Season Structure

Rather than committing to indefinite episodes, plan in seasons:

• Season length: 6-12 episodes is typical for nonprofit podcasts

• Release schedule: Weekly, biweekly, or monthly

• Season arc: What narrative or thematic throughline connects episodes?

Seasons provide natural evaluation points and prevent indefinite commitment without assessment.

Episode Planning

For each episode, define:

• Topic and angle

• Guest(s) if applicable

• Key points to cover

• Target length (20-45 minutes is typical)

• Connection to mission and listener value

Plan your first season before recording anything. This reveals whether you actually have enough material and prevents mid-season scrambling.

Recording Logistics

Location options:

• Professional studio (highest quality, highest cost)

• Quiet office space with proper equipment

• Remote recording with good software

• Combination approaches

Equipment needs:

• Quality microphones (USB mics work for starting out)

• Headphones for monitoring

• Recording software or hardware

• Quiet space with minimal echo

Remote recording considerations:

• Platform choice (Riverside, Zencastr, Zoom with proper settings)

• Guest equipment requirements

• Backup recording methods

• Internet reliability

Editing and Production

Raw recordings need editing:

• Removing filler words and awkward pauses

• Balancing audio levels

• Adding intro/outro music

• Inserting any ads or sponsorship mentions

• Creating show notes and timestamps

This takes significant time. Plan 2-3 hours of editing per hour of final content for basic editing, more for heavily produced shows.

Decide: DIY or Partner?

DIY makes sense if:

• You have staff with audio skills and capacity

• Budget is extremely limited

• You want full creative control

Partnering makes sense if:

• Your team lacks audio expertise

• Staff time is more limited than budget

• Production quality is important to your goals

• You want professional guidance on concept and execution

A production partner can handle recording, editing, distribution, and show notes—freeing your team to focus on content and guests.

Step 3: Create Your Show Identity

Naming Your Podcast

Your podcast name should:

• Be memorable and searchable

• Communicate what listeners will get

• Connect to your organization (but not necessarily be your org name)

• Sound good spoken aloud

Avoid generic names that could be any podcast. Avoid overly clever names that confuse.

Visual Identity

You'll need:

• Cover art (1400x1400 pixels minimum) that works at small sizes

• Consistent visual template for episode graphics

• Color palette and style that connects to your brand

Cover art is surprisingly important—it's the first impression in podcast apps.

Audio Identity

Intro/outro elements:

• Theme music that sets the right tone

• Opening that hooks and establishes the show

• Closing that drives appropriate action

Keep intro/outro tight—listeners skip long introductions.

Step 4: Launch and Distribution

Podcast Hosting

You need a hosting platform that stores your audio and generates your RSS feed:

Popular options include Buzzsprout, Libsyn, Anchor (free), and Transistor. Consider:

• Storage limits and pricing

• Analytics quality

• Distribution features

• Website integration

Directory Submission

Submit your podcast to:

• Apple Podcasts

• Spotify

• Google Podcasts

• Amazon Music

• Other relevant platforms

This is typically one-time setup that your hosting platform can guide you through.

Launch Strategy

Don't just release and hope. Plan your launch:

Pre-launch:

• Build anticipation through existing channels

• Create episode teasers

• Reach out to guests' networks

Launch:

• Release 2-3 episodes so new listeners can binge

• Coordinate email, social, and website announcement

• Ask supporters to listen, subscribe, and review

Post-launch:

• Consistent promotion with each episode

• Cross-promotion with guests

• Repurpose audio into other content

Step 5: Sustain and Grow

Consistency Is Everything

Irregular publishing kills podcast audiences. Whatever schedule you set, maintain it:

• Build a content buffer (2-3 episodes ahead)

• Protect production time from other demands

• Plan around organizational busy periods

• Have backup content for emergencies

Measure and Adjust

Track metrics against your goals:

• Downloads per episode (and trends)

• Listener retention (how much of each episode is heard)

• Engagement (reviews, shares, responses)

• Mission outcomes (donations, volunteer signups, etc.)

After each season, honestly assess: Is this working? Should we continue?

Repurpose Content

One podcast episode can yield:

• Blog post summarizing key points

• Social media clips and quotes

• Email newsletter content

• Video clips if recording with video

• Transcripts for accessibility and SEO

Don't let good content live only in audio form.

Common Nonprofit Podcast Mistakes

Starting without capacity: Enthusiasm launches podcasts; capacity sustains them. Be realistic about ongoing time requirements.

Inconsistent publishing: Better to publish monthly consistently than weekly inconsistently. Pick a schedule you can maintain.

Ignoring audio quality: Listeners tolerate imperfect content but not painful audio. Invest in basic quality before launching.

No clear value proposition: "We talk about our mission" isn't compelling. What specifically does your podcast offer listeners they can't get elsewhere?

Expecting instant growth: Podcast audiences build slowly. Plan for a 1-2 year investment before expecting significant reach.

Abandoning mid-stream: An abandoned podcast is worse than no podcast. Commit for a season minimum, with evaluation points planned.

Is Now the Right Time?

A podcast can be powerful for the right organization at the right time. But it's not the only way to tell your story.

Before committing, ask:

• Do we have the stories and capacity?

• Is our audience actually podcast listeners?

• Can we commit to consistency for at least a year?

• What's our specific goal, and is a podcast the best path to it?

If the answers are positive, a podcast can become one of your most valuable communication tools—deepening relationships with supporters, amplifying your mission's voice, and building a community around your cause.

Considering a podcast for your organization? Let's discuss whether it's the right fit and how to make it work.

[Schedule a Discovery Call]